The American TV show To Catch a Predator (2004-2007) was always a bit squicky, always a bit lowest common denominator, its popularity suggesting things we don’t want to confront about ourselves. The paradox was that it appeared to be doing a universal good, ridding the world of dangerous sexual predators, one dangerous sexual predator at a time.
The show involved a so-called “decoy,” an actor who looked young playing much younger, who had theoretically been involved in an online chat with an older man prepared to molest them. This actual online chat was the work of other people. Once the man was lured to a house to have a sexual encounter with the child, the show’s host, Chris Hansen, would spring from a back room, accompanied by cameras, to question the man who now knew his life was about to change forever – or more dramatically, that his life was over. The police awaited outside to arrest the perpetrator.
All good, right? Well, not so much, even if the ends did justify the means on occasion. There were certainly occasions where the ends were unjustifiable. The new movie Primetime, directed by Lance Oppenheim, is the second film in the past calendar year to shine a spotlight on the questionable practices and moral compromises of a TV show that, this movie suggests, was just trying to beat the juggernaut twist-a-week series Lost, which was appearing in the same time slot on another network. The first was David Osit’s Predators, a 2025 documentary that looks at many of the same events portrayed in Primetime, though probably can’t get inside the head of Hansen and his cohorts the way a narrative treatment of the same subject, with its acceptable dramatic license, can do.
And the Hansen we get, courtesy of Robert Pattinson, is a squicky one indeed. This is a man nearly collapsing from a depravity within, even though he thinks of himself as a hero and a moral paragon, and is not outwardly guilty of anything but an extramarital affair and perhaps some good old-fashioned neglect of his wife (Anna Faris) and children in the name of his job. Hansen was a mainstream reporter for the news show Dateline NBC who found his calling on a routine assignment to cover the victims of child sexual exploitation in Southeast Asia, and parlayed that into a show that became among the most popular on the network during a time of great transition in the TV industry. Seeming on the outside like a slick perfectionist who would read his script dozens of times to ensure every inflection was just right, this version of Hansen is more defined by his facial twitches, his faltering smiles, and eyes that blink too much, barely concealing that there is something deeply wrong with this person.
The show’s producer, Andie Bender (Merritt Wever), is more human, but still pretty far down in that same muck as Hansen. Another network is trying to lure her away for a show going for the same reality boom but less nauseating in nature, and the executive (Jessica Hecht) warns her that Chris is not a good person to hold hands with on her career path. As the narrative goes, we learn how true that is.
The other main character is the male of the two decoys, Dan Plum (Skyler Gisondo). He’s an aspiring actor just looking for his SAG card, so the 23-year-old accepts the assignment because he can play 13. His female counterpart is Del, played by singer-songwriter Phoebe Bridgers. Even though Dan is made queasy by what he’s asked to do – he actually has to meet these men, even if just for a second, before handing them over to Hansen – he’s sold the lie that he’s an unproblematic hero. We see how problematic this heroism is when one particular shoot goes particularly poorly.
There’s a complicated goal pursued in Primetime, which is to show how people trying to do good things might really be bad, and bad people, doing horrible things, might just be human beings deserving of compassion. The array of men who show up for their 15 minutes of humiliation – interestingly enough, played in two cases by former child actors, Tony Revolori and Jonathan Lipnicki – are notable not for being monsters, the type Hansen imagines in his dark nights of the soul, hiding in the shadows wearing ghoulish masks. They are notable for being confused people who can’t explain what has happened to cause their life to arrive at this moment, and are just feeling the weight of that accumulated sadness. At the same time the film asks you to be disgusted with these men for their actual and potential crimes, it also asks you to remember their core humanity.
And it asks you to consider the motivations of the people trying to jail them. Both of the last two cinematic considerations of To Catch a Predator arrive during a couple years of heightened focus on the Epstein Files, which threatened to expose the most high-profile paedophiles in the highest positions of power and fame. Even though their hero they elected president is likely one of these, the right-swing supporters of Donald Trump have demonstrated an unseemly level of enthusiasm about bringing these perpetrators to justice. They personify the same paradox that is examined in Primetime, that any cudgel you wield for good can have shameful collateral damage, and can reveal a thirst for blood that itself is off-putting.
Oppenheim gives this film a sweaty, claustrophobic feel, favouring intense close-ups of the performers, not to mention borrowing from horror tropes whenever he can. Never for a moment are we under the impression that Hansen is doing something noble here, though the film is too sophisticated to really suggest that he’s only a charlatan looking for ratings. In this way, the exceptional performance by Pattinson also personifies the right-wing movement to turn out the members of secret sex cabals, and all the gross trimmings that come along with it.
Primetime isn’t subtle, but neither is it a simplistic indictment of Hansen or these predators. It may not have the profound impact of Predators, quite simply one of the best documentaries of the last five years, but then again, the truth of this whole sordid affair is always going to be stranger and sadder than any attempt to recreate it with actors.
Primetime is currently playing in Australian cinemas.



